 | [03.11.2012] AnimeFanaticBoy » Sail Until The End [Feanor100] | You don't seem like a kind of 'Novice' author, I like that 
The situation is that there are general thoughts about the amvs. Some can say you need a 'Ultra-New-revolutionary' amv, while I'm with the part that believes that as long as the video is enjoyable and makes the viewer rewatch it again and again, that's already a sucess.
But I disagree: You can't really say (at least about the asocciation) that people here are youtubers when several of them don't even have a Yt account or are related with the concept of 'Viewer and not Critic' one
Don't get discouraged. Take your time to see and study the amvs from several authors here. You'll realize how you'll do in the future. I can even help you with betatesting, you just have to ask me or any of the critics here  |
|
 | [02.11.2012] RTW47 » Sail Until The End [Feanor100] | | Alazavra @ 02 November 2012, 21:56 | | man fedebankai, gregz, loosecontroi etc. are awesome editors |
encourage them to participate
| Alazavra @ 02 November 2012, 21:56 | | most of us here (maybe all) are youtubers |
definition pls |
|
 | [02.11.2012] DemonKurama » Dead Bite [bluEyEz] | | It wasn't bad. Didn't expect it to end there, though. It lacked some sort of climax. 8/10 |
|
 | [02.11.2012] Mystyk » Aparicion [Gattino] | | this is very nice! good idea, however I think there were some strange zooms, and some transition or effects could have been smoother, but overall nice job 8/10 |
|
 | [02.11.2012] Feanor100 » Sail Until The End [Feanor100] | | DemonKurama @ 02 November 2012, 18:08 | On youtube most viewers would say "cool" "awesome" etc. just because they are fans of one piece. Yet you would hardly receive any objective critisism there. It's kinda hard to explain. See authors like fedebankai, gregz, loosecontroi etc. they are kings of youtube style.
In contests people are expecting to see something amazing and original so everyone literally butchers amvs with overused anime scenes such as this. Unless, of course the author manages to make something technically amazing but that takes skill. Certainly you can enter the contest with whatever you want but such videos don't really stand a chance to win. Nothing unexpected here. Just saying...
Don't be discouraged though. If you improve your editing skills and choose a more original source you'll definitely have better chances here. Good luck. |
man fedebankai, gregz, loosecontroi etc. are awesome editors even if u say they are the "kings" of youtube style... their videos are really nice and artistic and also most of us here (maybe all) are youtubers(correct me if im wrong) and we have wathced the top one piece amv. other than that i can understand what you mean about youtube style now, but whats wrong about a cool video? the fact is that the one who used the scened first he got the most feedback and we just found the same scenes and thought they would fit our video very well so we used them... you are right about everything u say, but since we all are influenced from youtube , its impossible not to make videos like those u mentioned. however there are always some exception and i personally try not to make amv that look like "youtube style"(just trying, as u can see i m far from perfect :D) |
|
|
| |
| THE HIGHEST NUMBER OF VOTES | |
|
|  | RahXephon |
|  | Frou Frou - Must Be Dreaming |
|  | Drama, Serious |
|
|
|
|
