 | [03.11.2012] Finder » Haruhi in wonderland [Kronas] | | Понравилась подача. Идея улавливается на ура. Но, в угоду этому синхра почти "забыта". Не понравился липсинг в большинстве случаев. "Липсинг либо делать хорошо, либо совсем не делать" (с) |
|
| [03.11.2012] Finder » Fortitude [JustEmma] | | Действительно хорошо. Если бы ещё чуть менее "голубой" исходник, было бы наверно ещё лучше. Ну имеем, что имеем. |
|
 | [03.11.2012] [madaraxD] » Aparicion [Gattino] | | Best so far for me. 8/10. Nice story, technically can be better, but nice story. Great job! |
|
 | [03.11.2012] ZaRish » Fortitude [JustEmma] | | Наконец-то нормальный экшн с нормальным МВ. То музыка неуместная, то стрельба сплошная... Тут славо богу хоть этого нет. 7/10 |
|
 | [03.11.2012] ZakStorm » Fortitude [JustEmma] | Мне одному кажеться или AMV-ки стали всё короче и короче...неплохо, но ещё работать и работать))  |
|
 | [03.11.2012] AnimeFanaticBoy » Sail Until The End [Feanor100] | You got some points, but still:
| Feanor100 @ 03 November 2012, 08:35 | | who hasnt seen : "This Is One Piece"? |
I haven't 
Also:
| Feanor100 @ 03 November 2012, 08:35 | | do you think that these guys (famous editors) would listen to the opinion of a single guy |
Are they famous? 
Also, how many times have they participated in the AKROSS Con or any Contest outside YouTube? The reason: Some of them are already warned about the differences between their 'Comfortable Zone' and the 'Outside Zone'
I have talked with some of them at least once, so don't think I don't really know them, but everytime I mention AKROSS or Big Contest, they always end putting useless excuses. So why so scared? You don't want to take a real challenge?
And... if they are stuck into a 'security zone' that means that they will keep making the same and the same and the same style many times. Personally, that's discouraging, because the function of a feedback is to help the author improve, also seeing a repetition of the same bothers. Please notice that even the most skilled editors can't believe in lies like thinking they can't improve anymore. Like saying: All my amvs are perfect, if you don't think the same, you're a loser etc, etc, etc.
That means that is more important the ego rather than the edition of the video. You got a point: If this is a hobby, you're supposed to enjoy the making of a video. If you're not enjoying the making, you're just losing the time.
And considering YouTube is one of the most viewed sites of videos, yes, any normal person can say he/she has watched videos from the site. But I disagree: YouTube as an influence? How?
The 'YouTube style' expression is just a reflection of doing bad in amvs or simply making averages videos.
You even said it: It will be sad if only author him/herself enjoys the video, cause at the end, you'll get that annoying feeling of "I believe my friends should watch it" then other people, and then you'll need attention. It's normal
That's curious that you mention the critic level:
Did you know that I'm not obligated to watch your video, but I still do it?
Reason: That's my way to show respect to the creator. The creator took the time to make the video, no matter good or bad, as another editor, I watch it, because we share the same passion.
If I just ignore it, that means I don't care about it, and that's a terrible way to be a critic, an editor and a judge. I'm a betatester that can say you that, if I don't take the time to think about what I'll say about the video.
I agree with you: I dislike useless comments. You remind me myself when I first made my ever first video when I was 12 years old 10 years ago.
And don't worry about the comments. You're free to keep commenting. I can extend you a hand in future videos  |
|
|
| |
|
|  | Kodomo no Jikan |
|  | D.C. OST |
|  | Drama |
|
|
|
|
