|
| Video |
Various [ Persona 3, Persona 4, Selector Infected WIXOSS, Selector Spread Wixoss, Gundam 00, Ao no Excorcist, Rewrite, Blood C, Steins;Gates ] |
|
| Audio |
Poets of the Fall - Carnival of Rust |
|
| Genre |
Romance, Thriller, Character Profile |
|
| Only registered memebers can vote and comment videos! |
|
|
| |
| RATING |
| AVERAGE SCORE: | 5.3 / 10 | | 51 | | RATING POSITION: | 2392 / 2996 |
| TOTAL SCORES: | 48 |
|
|
| VIEWERS: | 5.9 (20) | CRITICS: | 4.5 (11) | | EDITORS: | 5.1 (16) | EXPERTS: | 4.0 (1) |
|
|
|
|
Это сцена с девочкой в ярко красном платье.
На премьерном показе здоровые мужики рыдали после неё. И прекрасно понимая какой эмоциональный смысл и эффект может оказать на зрителя банальный цветовой контраст, я задаю банальный вопрос.
Что оно оказывает здесь ?...
совсем
где история для триллера?
чей профайл вообще пытался раскрыться?
ну да - имеются формальные признаки романтики
В смысловую / сюжетную линию не въехал, (если она и присутствует), но эстетика нравится.
if I write detailed criticism for each video — right now I wouldn't have written anything...
I'm only saying details for authors that I personally think have potential
you may think I'm some king of elite-asshole
but I'm just lazy-asshole :)
who said is masterpiece? It's just video w/o technical errors and w/ good music\video combination.
It's not enough?
At what point does saying that is bad help the editor who made the video? ...
Saying that is crap or that is wrong does not help at all, if I put a good criticism instead of just saying this is bad I accept it, but what does that help besides the editor who did it feel bad?
I did not see any criticism in his comment, so he stops defending t
hings that have no meaning ..
At what point did I say that his AMV was good or that he defended it? I defend that Artofeel's comment is offensive ...
and that's what should mean? You can do awfull amvs but you still have the right to say what you think about, let the author takes comments as he/she wants. Even if Artofeel did a bad work ( and he didn't) he is an experienced author so you should at least try to think about the reasons why he said that. Comments are the best way to improve our work, if you want to hear just " wow !11!!! best amv evaaaa" go on youtube
For the vid itself: it's too random, it has good ideas behind but the execution is not on point, those "shakes" around 0.25 were really bad as some transition not really smooth and in general the vid was very confused. Try to be more clean next time, it's pretty clear that you had good intentions