The beggining feels very strong, but you start to be loose after that. I think you used very well the imaginery of the series, specially clips from Rebellion, but I think it doesn't have the necesary atmosphere at some points. The song gives me an ethereal feeling, like floating in a trance state, but clips doesn't bring me that, some parts felt "fast". Still, I think this is one of the best madoka videos I've seen in a while, and your technique is very good.
guys, there's a comparison of amvs in the comments of about every other entry solely because of the song or anime choice. i don't get why now is the time to make a big deal of it.
anyway, i think the video is pretty good. while nothing special conceptually, the flow and sync are very solid from beginning to end and it's a really easy watch. 8
FobosAMV No where, but if you're gonna senselessly compare amvs with similar songs, I'll senselessly compare two editors. Just like this dumbfuck artofeel down here. Pandora's bonfires already had a good AMV before it, where's the mockery on that, she did a great job too.
Comparing different concept amvs with different anime is very stupid. While we're at it, let's compare you to shin as an editor as well. Let me find his worst AMV and your best.
FobosAMV Because other humans were born before you, I guess I can't take you seriously either, you must also be a trash human being because other people came before you, there for you have no merit or value down to your existance and your cells should no longer replicate.
Are we doing homage to music, or are AMVs not their own artform? I don't understand this mentality that there can be only one good AMV per song, it's narrow-minded.
I think you used very well the imaginery of the series, specially clips from Rebellion, but I think it doesn't have the necesary atmosphere at some points. The song gives me an ethereal feeling, like floating in a trance state, but clips doesn't bring me that, some parts felt "fast".
Still, I think this is one of the best madoka videos I've seen in a while, and your technique is very good.
anyway, i think the video is pretty good. while nothing special conceptually, the flow and sync are very solid from beginning to end and it's a really easy watch. 8
No where, but if you're gonna senselessly compare amvs with similar songs, I'll senselessly compare two editors. Just like this dumbfuck artofeel down here. Pandora's bonfires already had a good AMV before it, where's the mockery on that, she did a great job too.
No, bcz we already have strong clip with this song and no need make this one.
And where i say that im better than shin, huh? Thats all, bye.
Comparing different concept amvs with different anime is very stupid.
While we're at it, let's compare you to shin as an editor as well. Let me find his worst AMV and your best.
http://amvnews.ru/index.php?go=Files&in=view&id=5547 > http://amvnews.ru/index.php?go=Files&in=view&id=6146 * 500
Why you take already used effect ? I can't understand
Because other humans were born before you, I guess I can't take you seriously either, you must also be a trash human being because other people came before you, there for you have no merit or value down to your existance and your cells should no longer replicate.