| FT - Adventurers |
 | MikuriAki (1) | | Красиво, технично, есть история, ничего лишнего |
 | TritioAFB (1) | | Muy impresionante muchacho. Aunque no tenga mucho tiempo de conocerte siempre es agradable ver tus trabajos, esperando ver que puedes hacer en el futuro |
 | JawaProg (2) | | Красивый клип и хорошая музыка. Как по мне, этого достаточно для победы) |
 | JustRukia (2) | | Просто хорошая, стабильная такая работа. Опять же из-за такого выбора музыки и видео создается впечатление, что смотришь опенинг к этому аниме. Это всегда такое довольно читерское решение, но это не отменяет все достоинств данной работы. Единственное, что я бы посоветовал сделать это следить за общим темпом повествования (сменами кадров и динамикой сцен). Это же не экшан, чтобы куда-то спешить и быстро менять кадров и ускорять без того быстрые пролеты камеры. Вообщем нужно учиться держать правильный баланс спокойных и быстрых моментов относительно музыки и будет просто отлично. |
| ShinOri (2) | | color blending is good. I also like the 3d scene |
 | TakeshiAMV (2) | | Nice video, in my opinion this could even get 1st place in my personal top of this contest if there was a better sync, sometimes you went too hard with it syncing beats you could skip and this affects me from enjoying some good scenes you selected. Anyway I like the effects and how you managed to show the most important moments of this movie. |
 | Nero_09 (3) | I was fascinated by the music selection, scene selection, and careful cut editing that matched the world view of "Suzume no Tojimari".
The video was very carefully produced, and the expressions and emotions of the characters were conveyed along with the music. |
|
| ShinOri - Eternal World |
 | Anima Purgatorius (1) | | Этот клип я высоко оценил не за технику или оригинальность, по этим параметрам он не выдающийся, один из многих. Но зато автору удалось вложить в работу хорошее позитивное начало. Показать что-то доброе таким образом, чтобы в него поверили: это на самом деле требует немало мастерства и самоотдачи. И наверное, веры в то что делаешь. За это стоило поставить высший балл. |
| JustRukia (1) | | Крайне приятно видеть столь замечательную работу. В которой есть все, что нужно для правильного настроения и даже своего рода погружения. На одном моменте я даже вспомнил давно забытое чувство прекрасного, как видео ряд прекрасно передает тональности музыки. В целом это правильная и прекрасная работа со всех точек зрение (такие работы это моя слабость). |
| Nero_09 (1) | I think the AMV was the highest quality of any of the films and had a sense of unity throughout the entire video.
I was drawn in by the storied, colorful world of the AMV, with its many animated characters traveling through a beautiful world.
I am glad to have found this wonderful AMV!! |
 | okhostok (1) | | This video is the most effortful video in the contest. I liked how dedicated author was. |
| TakeshiAMV (1) | | Great video even though there are some technical mistakes regarding masks, effects and sync (there are changes of rythm and some roll of beats that could be followed better). Moreover, I think your scene selection in some points lacks of "personality" and it feels generic due to abuse of openings/endings, PVs and clips already seen in many other amvs. Despite that your overall work conveys a nice, chill atmosphere and I appreciate the effort. |
 | FT (3) | | A pretty great entry, good atmosphere, combo and execution. |
 | MesoGear (3) | | Неплохой подбор материала и местами монтаж, не выглядит как пародия на Ностромо |
| Picman (3) | | Very smooth and "starry", the technics used to combine all sorts of footages are awesome. |
|
| Nero_09 - 美徳ト悪徳 |
 | Bean d'Тінь (1) | This one is really good and I give this one first place because it invites you into a action packed opening style video. The profiles in the beginning of the amv were made beautifully. then we have them showing some of the people they have to battle getting corrupted then we see them getting corrupted. all of the action scenes flowed perfectly in sync from one scene to the next.
I had trouble understanding proportions of the ending but I put that up to being never watching the series. yes I have never watched chainsaw man a series that has probably made on the top of my head guess 10 of the last two years. I was finishing the end of the Netflix DVD library (a disc sending rental service which is where that streaming service actually came from). anyway I still give it first place because it is not the videos for that I do not watch what seems to possibly be the most popular anime is of the last year. (even though I did look it up after last year) this is a good opening that drives people in. |
| Picman (2) | | Best technical work at this year's contest, visually impressive while not being asset-abused, better than that Nero had done last year. |
| JawaProg (3) | | Понравилась техническое исполнение. Трек тоже качает. Никаких заморочек с сюжетом - просто смотри и наслаждайся |
| ShinOri (3) | | insane technical skill, very hardworking editor |
|
| bloodSlayer - One of the Starry Girls |
| ShinOri (1) | | Very nice flow |
 | kain4ig (2) | | Очень хороший клип и красивый. |
| JustRukia (3) | | Несмотря на вполне стандартное сочетание музыки и видео и неполноту (отсутствие структуры в клипе), данной работа собрана качественно и приятно для просмотра с точки зрение визуала. Единственный недостаток в визуальном плане, это перебор с миганием не в ритм музыки, что немного подпорчивает приятную работу. |
| TritioAFB (3) | | Que bueno ver que también llegaste a tiempo. La verdad me sorprendió ver tu entrada bastante decente y aceptable. Buen trabajo |
|
| JustRukia - Sacrifice |
| FT (1) | | The video is simple, but the execution is really good. You can notice a solid and characteristic style on the editing, in addition the video is very enjoyable |
| MesoGear (1) | | Эта работа показалась наиболее приличной |
| Picman (1) | | JustRukia did a great job combining the outstanding storyline of 2B and 9S, as well as vividly editing the action scenes. |
| okhostok (2) | | Мне нравиться вся медленная часть клипа, они создают очень хорошую атмосфера. В экшен частьях сильно не хватает синхры. |
| TritioAFB (2) | | Its a pleasure to see that you were able to finish in time. And also good to see your evolution through time. Expecting to see more of you in the future |
|
| Takeshi & Fobos - The Impossible Escape |
 | FobosAMV (1) | | Не ну раз в этот раз тож моно голосовать, то чё нет то ? Клип, скорее всего, так и останется недооцененным (если нет, можете кинуть в меня помидорку, я поймаю ее и заберу, хыхых). |
| Bean d'Тінь (2) | I had trouble deciding second place (I had first and third without a Second) and the decision was made a little faster than it was going to by a miss press of a button in the middle of filling in that form out by accident for the third time because the second time I took too long and did not accept my submission. but even though I am trying to list a reason (some of which was inspired by your description I made of each video just in case I made it to the finals. which when I reviewed yours was actually just a unlikely dream.) it is more of a pros and cons list of five different videos competing for the spot. I started to realise that I was favouring action videos on biased and this emotional one would even that up. I will say that your seamless effects is what give you the edge.
anyhow, this has many amazing effects and it has a powerful message. though at first view I feel there was just something missing but rewatching it again I am not sure why I thought that (look more into it later). every scene flowed together the dissolving scenes were made good. this is relies heavily on special effects which is also a weakness and One of the reasons I might not have originally gotten second place because too much of the story and more difficult to piece the story since they are is tied up to this. making it ranked slightly lower. |
| Anima Purgatorius (3) | | Здесь авторы хорошо проработали эмоциональную сторону клипа. В целом, при просмотре казалось, что сюжет может стать скучным и однообразным, но эмоциональное движение держит определённый накал и не даёт заскучать. Ну и кадры выразительные, подобраны хорошо. |
|
| Picman - SLAVE & MASTER |
| kain4ig (1) | | Клип понравился суперно крута. |
| MikuriAki (2) | | Хорошая работа с графикой, хоть иногда и перебор. Технично, красивый визуал |
|
| TakeshiAMV - Wanted Dead or Alive |
| FobosAMV (2) | | Отличный клип, техническое исполнение тоже и все такое. Автор знает мое мнение:) |
| FT (2) | | My fav of the Con, good combo and enjoyable clip in overall. |
| MesoGear (2) | | МВ в тему, неплохо поймана атмосфера |
| Bean d'Тінь (3) | I have to say I like the older style of amv editing, something that is pretty obvious the moment you press my profile. The storytelling was great following the music perfectly. I realised in attempting to review this , something that took a few times to even make a sentence, that to do such a thing would involve go on the lyrics by lyrics and storyline notes. I think the best way is that this this video told the story good. from showing childhood moments to Showing his journey of trying to go from day to day as the solitary main character, a very popular style of main character. I enjoyed 'the bottle that you drink' which I laughed that in a good way.
this was third place because a lot of the scenes were not transitioned smoothly (not enough crossphases) and were very blunt and sometimes not perfectly timed. there were also issues in terms of some of the lyrics that involved a lot more assuming that I would have preferred. ("all you do is think" was one of and "a steel horse I ride" I wish I had more driving scenes timed out the word steel instead of horse and not just once which could be put up to a trying to fit the source where is just not fitting) if the issue to that is related to language barrier then I am sorry but realistically steel horse is a single item. because it was not smooth and some of the lyrics were slightly off or are heavily needing of context making me have to move it down from a top spot. |
|
| Visual Reality Studios - Starboy |
| FobosAMV (3) | | Тоже продвину, пожалуй, пока законом не запрещено. На деле же получился и правда отличный меп, который посматривал в течении всего кона, как-то так. |
|
| Picman - Collapse |
 | Deviant (1) | | Единственный клип, который мне было интересно (по)смотреть. |
|
| Waku Waku - Ведьмак: Дикая работа |
| Nero_09 (2) | I don't think I have ever seen an AMV with such a high quality trailer.
I liked the way the images were cut and the text was well-done, but most of all I was mesmerized by the way the sound effects were put in. It was like a real Attack on Titan trailer.
It was wonderful!! |
| Deviant (3) | | Просто хороший трейлер. А большего мне и не надо :) |
|
| FobosAMV - The Last 9 Days (2nd Quincy Invasion) |
| kain4ig (3) | | Клип тоже очень очень хороший. |
| MikuriAki (3) | | Хорошая техника, есть история, хороший подбор музыка\<исходник, ничего не напрягает при просмотре |
| TakeshiAMV (3) | | Pretty good job, there is not much to say, it is a clean action video with our daily dose of drink (BLEACH!) without any crazy good or bad things, it flows well. In my opinion the song you used penalized you a bit because it works with this anime as it can work with others, anyway loved the outro. |
|
| MesoGear - Disgusting |
| JawaProg (1) | | Понравилась техническая работа (сочетание исходного аниме с добавленными лицами и людьми). Ну эти лица вызывают смех (чуть чуть напоминают этим Момо), мне нравится) |
| Anima Purgatorius (2) | | Клип выделяется среди других, в нём достаточно нестандартно поставлены сцены, и присутствует авторское видение темы. Специфически обыграны бытовые вроде бы ситуации. Думаю, это заслуживает хорошей оценки. |
| Deviant (2) | | Единственный клип, который мне было интересно (до)смотреть. |
| okhostok (3) | | Рожа Афекса - вин. Среди большинства клишированных клипов это как глоток свежего воздуха, оригинально. |
|
|
|
|
| |
|
